Book Report: “The Greeks and Greek Love”

Published July 21, 2015 by Iphis of Scyros

Heh, sorry for the silly “Book Report” title, but I am a student, right? (And you can tell I composed this off-line in a word processor and then copy-pasted, ‘cause I have accented letters! Ooh, fancy! Maybe there’s a sole advantage to my computer being down. Sigh.)

Anyway, since I’ve finally finished reading The Greeks and Greek Love by James Davidson, I thought I’d give you a run-down on the highlights. But the bottom line, of course, is that if you’re interested in the social/homosocial/homosexual history of ancient Greece, you should definitely read this book, because it’s very thoroughly researched, and the writing style is very light and engaging. (Despite how long it took me to read it, which had more to do with the fact that I tend to spend most of my time playing games and blogging than anything to do with the book itself.)

Much of the early historical work on homosexuality in ancient Greece (*cough*cough*Dover*cough*cough*) and most of the current popular perception of the ancient Greeks is that there was one set of homosexual behavioral patterns in use, obeying one theoretical model. One of Davidson’s major points is that just as in all other matters, in their attitudes towards homosexuality, the ancient Greeks were widely varied, because what we now call “ancient Greece” was a collection of independent city-states spread across a number of centuries. There’s a good summary from the conclusion:

 From such wide-ranging explorations we can draw one uncontroversial conclusion straightaway: There were lots of different kinds of homosexuality in ancient Greece rather than one single mos Graecorum. It manifests itself differently in different materials, in paint or in poetry; in different places, Elis or Macedonia; in different times, fourth-century Athens or archaic Lesbos c. 600 BC. It is a rather different thing when the lovers are Spartan women, gods and heroes, comrades-in-arms or master and slave. There is the bloodthirsty self-sacrificing love of Achilles for his “dear companions,” the sweet and playful erōs of the Lyric poets, the patriotic erōs of Pericles’ funeral speech, the eros of Plato’s Academy, ambitious for knowledge, the erōs of the potter’s quarters, exporting to the four corners of the ancient world acclamation of the beauty of local boys, the erōs of the monument to the Tyrant Slayers, the whorish homosexuality of Aeschnes’ speech “Against Timarchus,” and of the strange letters supposed to have been written by Alexander, forcefully rejecting ill-conceived offers to send him the most beautiful boys in the world, the squalid, squabbling homosexual lust of Lysias’ speech “Against Simon,” the rampant katapugones of Aristophanes and the writers of graffiti, the monstrous, seductive, predator kinaidoi, the rather too obvious sexual proclivities of Misgolas and Autoclides mocked in the fragments of the comic poets of the fourth century BC, the same-sex sex acts Plato would like to discourage in Laws on the grounds that they don’t conform with nature.

Yeah, Plato’s on there twice. (He changed his mind as he turned into a bitter old man. As far as anyone can tell, anyhow.)

Due to the computer going down and preventing me from writing this up closer to when I finished the book, it’s already growing fuzzy in my malfunctioning brain cells (well, there’s also the fact that I’ve been going nuts panicking over the computer, and various other things going weird/wrong/crazy since then) I’m having trouble calling to mind all the things I wanted to say about the book, and the order in which I wanted to say them. The really big thing I want to talk about—its impact on my writing, re: the relationship between Achilles and Patroclos—should be its own post, so I’ll give that a teaser and say that he provided an explanation for that particularly erotic Aischylos fragment that I would never have guessed at, and which—while an awesome explanation—would completely shatter a lot of my fiction if I accepted it as “the” version. (Then again, it’s just one ancient author’s version, so it’s not like I’d have to accept it.) Anyway, that’s going to be its own post, so look forward to it. (If you’re into Achilles/Patroclos and/or listening to me whine about my lousy fiction-writing.)

I mentioned a while ago that one of the chapters informed me that men in ancient Greece hit puberty much later, about eighteen years old. They were also strictly protected until they hit puberty, as well. So all the stuff about romancing a “boy” you hear in, say Plato’s Symposium? They’re talking about a “boy” between the age of eighteen and twenty. It was actually punishable by death to talk to a boy under eighteen if he didn’t have a chaperone of some sort around. So what about pots showing men and little boys? Well, Davidson suspects—and all anyone can do is guess, obviously, ‘cause the Greeks, unlike the later Romans, didn’t like to write about sex, so they tended to skirt around the issue—they were probably either “bad boy images” or images of “what not to do,” and “how not to behave.”

 Now it is quite possible that seducing under-Eighteens was a matter similar to the question of taking drugs in our own society, that there were ferocious laws againt it, universal condemnation, yet still it took place on a large scale. But the Peithinos Cup is not a window on reality, a news report. It is a work of art that demands to be read in context. It belongs to the same world of values as the texts, and cannot escape from it, any more than some modern portrait painter, dependent on aristocratic clients, who painted a huge exhibition canvas of schoolboys at Eton shooting up could escape from the context of the “War on Drugs.” Perhaps he might paint a true picture. Nevertheless it would be a gross error for future generations to interpret his image as a straightforward documentary photograph, a window on how things were. It would be, in other words, A Statement.

I think one way to define this book is in terms of what it doesn’t do. He doesn’t try to define the ancient Greeks en masse. He doesn’t try to explain their behavior by analogy to a modern group with no connection to them. He doesn’t try to use tenuous pychological theories to make nonsense out of fact.

 

Okay, that wasn’t actually such a good way to define the book, after all. (My head is not so much cleared up as I thought it was.) Basically, he looks at the original source texts—histories, myths and philosophical dialogues alike—and actually tries to understand them in context as much as anyone can, and then tries to extrapolate from there what was being said about homosexual behavior in the author’s society. It’s as sound a method as there can be, I think. The results are necessarily flawed, as any human action is, but short of a time machine, what won’t be, when you’re trying to get results about something so private over so many centuries?

 

Normally, when I read a book focused on only one aspect of something, I tend to find places where I’m like “oh, come on!” because there’s always something the author ignores or forces aside because it doesn’t fit their point. Really, the only thing here that gave me even a moment that approached that was that I felt like he didn’t give any weight at all to the heterosexual myths that had sprung up around characters like Achilles and Heracles in addition to their homosexual myths. (Which is not to deny the validity or antiquity of the homosexual variants. Just that the brushing aside of the bisexual side of the characters seemed a bit dismissive.)

One comment on “Book Report: “The Greeks and Greek Love”

Comments are closed.

Vocaloid Tarot

Vocaloid, UTAU and Tarot; individually or all-in-one

Matthew Meyer

the yokai guy

Arwen's Butterflies and Things

My BJD creation blog. Here's where my sewing creations and projects are showcased. Some outfits are for sale. Please use the tags & catagories to navigate this blog. I love comments and reviews!

History From Below

Musings on Daily Life in the Ancient and Early Medieval Mediterranean By Sarah E. Bond

The Bloggess

Like Mother Teresa, only better.

My Tiny Joy

Where little things matter!

Klein's Other Toys

Comics, Funko Pops and Anime figures oh my!

BINARYTHIS

EVERYTHING YOU ALWAYS WANTED TO KNOW ABOUT GENDER BUT WERE TOO AFRAID TO ASK

Creating Herstory

Celebrating the women who create history

Kicky Resin

BJDs et al

Lala Land

(>°~°)><(°~°<)

A'Cloth the World

Where Textiles, Fashion, Culture, Communication and Art Come Together.

starshiphedgehog

Occasionally my brain spurts out ideas and this is where I put them

The Social Historian

Adventures in the world of history

medievalbooks

Erik Kwakkel blogging about medieval manuscripts

Sara Letourneau

Poet. Freelance editor and writing coach. SFF enthusiast.

Zounds, Alack, and By My Troth

A tragical-comical-historical-pastoral webcomic by Ben Sawyer

Project Doll House

never too old to play with dolls

knotted things

All about the things that I'm all about.

Eclectic Alli

A bit of this, a bit of that, the meandering thoughts of a dreamer.

Omocha Crush

Secret Confessions of a Toy Addict

C.G.Coppola

FIND YOUR ESCAPE

Onomastics Outside the Box

Names beyond the Top 100, from many nations and eras

Hannah Reads Books

This is an archival site for old posts. Visit hannahgivens.com for art, puppetry, and links to any current media commentary.

Ariel Hudnall

the writings, musings, and photography of a dream smith

Taking a Walk Through History

Walking back in time to discover the origins of every historical route on earth

SENTENTIAE ANTIQUAE

ΕΥΔΟΞΑ ΑΓΝΩΣΤΑ ΚΑΤΑΓΕΛΑΣΤΑ

Pullips and Junk

We're all mad about Pullips here!

Dutch Fashion Doll World

A Dutch Barbie collector in Holland

Confessions of a Doll Collectors Daughter

Reviews and News From the Doll World

It's a Britta Bottle!

Small Stories of a Twenty-Something Adventuring Through Life

DataTater

It's all small stuff.

The Photographicalist

Preserving the photographical perspective

The Daily Post

The Art and Craft of Blogging

We're All Mad Here!

<---This Way | . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . | That Way--->

WordPress.com News

The latest news on WordPress.com and the WordPress community.

%d bloggers like this: